"A scathing report by a US bankruptcy-court examiner investigating the collapse of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. [LBHI] blames senior executives and auditor Ernst & Young [E&Y] for serious lapses that led to the largest bankruptcy in US history and the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression. ... The document runs thousands of pages and contains fresh allegations. In particular, it alleges that Lehman executives manipulated its balance sheet, withheld information from the board, and inflated the value of toxic real estate assets. ... The examiner said in the report that throughout the investigation it conducted regular weekly calls with the SEC and Department of Justice. There have been no prosecutions of Lehman executives to date. ... Mr. [Anton] Valukus, chairman of law firm Jenner & Block, devoted more than 300 pages alone to balance-sheet manipulation, accusing Lehman of using accounting methods to move assets off its books. But because the moved assets represented 105% or more of the cash it received in returns, accounting rules allowed the transactions to be treated as 'sales' rather than financings. The result: Assets shifted away from Lehman's balance sheet, reducing the amount of debt it showed to investors. ... Lehman's own global financial controller, Martin Kelly, told the examiner that 'the only purpose or motive for the transactions was reduction in balance sheet' and 'there was no substance to the transactions.' Mr. Kelly said he warned former Lehamn finance chiefs Erin Callan and Ian Lowitt about the maneuver, saying the transactions posed 'reputational risk' to Lehman if their use became publicly known. ... Mr. Valukus' report is among the largest undertakings of its kind. Those singled out in the report won't face immediate repercussions. Rather, the report provides a type of roadmap for Lehman's bankruptcy estate, creditors and other authorities to pursue possible actions against former Lehman executives, the bank's auditors and others involved in the financial titan's collapse. ... One party singled out in the report is Lehman's audit firm, [E&Y], which allegedly didn't raise concerns with Lehman's board about the frequent use of the repo transactions. ... '[E&Y] took no steps to question or challenge the non-disclosure by Lehman of its use of $50 billion of temporary off-balance sheet transactions,' Mr. Valukus wrote", Mike Spector, Susanne Craig & Peter Lattman at the WSJ, 12 March 2010, link:
"Many executives inside [LBHI] quietly fretted about the firm's accounting as the company headed to the brink in September 2008. Matthew Lee did something about it. In May 2008, the former Lehman senior vice president wrote a letter to senior management warning that the company may have been masking the true risks on its balance sheet. ... His warnings, disclosed for the first time in a report by a US bankruptcy-court examiner, could trigger legal consequences for Lehman's auditor [E&Y], as well as former senior officials. ... 'We are dealing with a whistle-blower letter, that is on its face pretty ugly and will take us a significant amount of time to get through,' William Schlich, a former lead partner on [E&Y's] Lehman team, wrote in a June 5, 2008, email to a colleague, which is included in the examiner's report. ... In a June 12, 2008 interview with [E&Y], Mr. Lee raised the issue that Lehman was moving as much as $50 billion off its balance sheet, using a practice the firm called 'Repo 105,' the report says", Michael Corkery at the WSJ, 13 March 2010, link: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703447104575118122594094284.html.
We know E&Y. Substance over form? From the Big 87654? You're joking! E&Y accepts the ".001 standard", my 5 March 2008 post: http://skepticaltexascpa.blogspot.com/2008/03/enron-accounting-redux.html. Did Uncle Sam know about LBHI's accounting chicanery? Probably. See my 6 February 2008 post: http://skepticaltexascpa.blogspot.com/2008/02/treasury-and-banks.html. Yves Smith has a related 11 March 2010 post at her Naked Capitalism: http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2010/03/ny-fed-under-geithner-implicated-in-lehman-accounting-fraud.html.
1 comment:
IA --- you wrote a year ago...
"As to repairing this mess, the first thing is to send the financiers to alcoholics anonymous to learn the 12 steps. There's something about rigorous honesty in there.
Next, tell everyone, Uncle Sam is broke. Defaults will come. Treasury bonds, social security, medicare, you name it.
Next, repeal the Federal Reserve Act and reverse the gold clause cases of the 1930s. Repeal the drug laws. Now, we can rest for a year and begin dealing with the fallout."
That's it...
Lehman is but one flavor of the whole collapse... a collapse in the rule of law... we became a society of "smoke and mirrors"... and the smoke is blowing away...
Post a Comment